Free Jewelry Appraisal in Naples
Bring your jewelry, silver, diamonds, watches, or coins to our Shirley St showroom and get a straight answer on what they're worth — tested and weighed in front of you, with a real cash offer you're free to walk away from.
Two very different things get called an "appraisal"
Most people asking for a jewelry appraisal want one of two things — and jewelers rarely explain the difference. We'd rather you know exactly what you're getting:
What we do
FreeMarket appraisal — with a real offer
What your piece is genuinely worth in today’s market, backed by a cash offer we’ll pay on the spot. Gold and silver weighed against live spot prices, stones examined, makers and hallmarks identified — all in front of you, in minutes.
There’s no fee and no obligation. If the number isn’t right for you, you walk out with your piece and a better understanding of it.
When you need paper
Written insurance appraisal
A formal document stating a retail replacement value, for insuring a piece you’re keeping. That number is typically far higher than what any buyer pays — it’s what a new replacement would cost, not what your piece sells for.
We don’t sell paperwork. If a written insurance appraisal is what you actually need, we’ll say so honestly and point you to a certified independent appraiser.
How Your Appraisal Works
Step 1
Walk in, or send photos first
Come by the Shirley St showroom during open hours, or text a few photos to (239) 404-8505 for a ballpark before you make the trip.
Step 2
Tested in front of you
Acid testing and XRF analysis for metals, loupe and gauge work for stones, maker and hallmark identification — and GIA coordination for significant diamonds.
Step 3
An honest number — and a real offer
You get the value explained piece by piece, backed by a cash offer we will pay on the spot. No pressure, no obligation if you decline.
What We Appraise
Gold jewelry
10k–24k chains, rings, and bracelets — worn or broken included.
Sterling silver
Flatware sets, tea services, hollowware, and .925 jewelry.
Diamonds
Engagement rings, studs, and tennis bracelets — certified or not.
Watches
Rolex, Omega, Cartier, and vintage pieces, running or not.
Coins & bullion
Gold and silver coins, bars, and junk silver of any mint.
Full estates
Complete collections for executors and families settling estates.
Appraisal FAQ
How much does a jewelry appraisal cost in Naples?
Ours are free. We make our living buying and selling jewelry, not charging for opinions — the appraisal comes with a real offer, and there is no obligation to accept it.
Is your appraisal the same as an offer?
Yes — that is the point. Instead of a hypothetical number, you get what we will actually pay, today, explained openly. You are always free to shop it around; a fair number holds up to comparison.
Do you prepare written insurance appraisals?
No — we do not sell paperwork. A written insurance appraisal states a retail replacement value for insuring a piece you are keeping, and it is a different service. If that is what you actually need, we will say so honestly and point you to a certified independent appraiser.
Do I need an appointment?
No — walk into our Shirley St showroom during open hours. Private appointments and home visits across Southwest Florida are available too.
How long does it take?
Most single pieces take minutes. Full estates and large flatware services take longer — we go through everything unhurried, in front of you.
Can you appraise inherited jewelry I know nothing about?
That is most of what we see. We identify makers, hallmarks, metals, and stones, and explain what matters and what does not — whether or not you sell.
Want to know what you have before you come in? Read our hallmark guide — or, if you are settling an estate, what to do first with inherited jewelry.
Want to know what your pieces are worth?
Free, private, no-obligation appraisal — at the showroom or in your home.